7 Comments
User's avatar
Daniel Harriman's avatar

Really nice update on $SCHW

Tidepool Investor's avatar

Regarding $FTCH, I'm not sure if everyone's paying attention (amidst the all the panic selling), but on the 2Q23 earnings call, mgt. actually mentioned that by year end (2023), they can get to 800M of cash on the balance sheet ("we now expect to deliver cash and cash equivalents of over $800 million at year end). Apparently I think this is significant - it would mean FTCH is guiding 170mn of FCF in 3Q/4Q EACH in order for cash balance to increase to 800mn from 454mn as of 6/30/23. If you annualize 170mn of FCF/Q, that's 680mn of steady state FCF, v. current 1.8Bn TEV, that's 40% yield on TEV. I mean whether or not they can deliver is a big ?, but I don't think people really went thru all the numbers and details on the FTCH 2Q23 call as they were desperately selling.

Vince Martin's avatar

two issues there, though. First, some of the cash is coming from a term loan that they're saying will give them $180M. Per the release, that draw came on August 11, so that's accounting for basically half of what you're talking about.

The second issue is that the second half is seasonally stronger, so you can't really annualize it. Some of the cash increase is coming from inventory reduction (which was abnormally elevated at 6/30 regardless) as they sell through the holidays, and Q4 performance should be much better than the rest of the year. (It wasn't in 2022, but in 2021 they did $36M in Q4 EBITDA and -$35M the first three quarters of the year.)

That said, they are definitely saying they think the second half will be stronger than the market believes. And I think that makes FTCH interesting through the Q4 release in February, given that the stock (as we noted) soared after recent earnings reports before this one.

Right now, though, investors just don't trust them. That's either a contrarian opportunity or a warning to stay away, and it's really difficult to determine which it is.

Tidepool Investor's avatar

Good point with the 180mn loan, which I missed. I guess that changes things a bit but still it does seem management is saying 2H is better than what the market expects.

But I find it funny that management can say with a straight face that 2025 GMV of 10Bn and 400mn of EBITDA (which implies 55% GMV CAGR from 2023-2025) and would mean the stock can 5-10x if they actually achieve 400mn EBITDA (4x multiple on current TEV).

Management keeps reiterating profitability at EBITDA and cash flow for FY23 which does show incremental improvements but then nobody is believing them at this point. I guess it comes down to needing a pickup in China/US macro and e-com luxury sales to show some improvement for the stock to find a bottom.

Vince Martin's avatar

yeah that sounds right. one broad issue here is that the business model itself has been questioned since the jump. Skeptics have long argued that the 'real' luxury brands won't ever cede pricing and distribution control to a third party, because luxury is *defined by* pricing and distribution. So if you don't get the actual luxury players, you wind up with a platform full of pseudo-luxury suppliers who probably go in and out of favor and thus create inconsistent growth at best.

So when they struggle, I think there's a sense that the numbers here just confirm the structural bear case, and that adds support to the idea that management can't/shouldn't be trusted - after all, they're running a flawed model but don't seem to know it yet.

again, that's the bear case - I'm more optimistic, and while I'm not long I think this stock has a pretty good chance of clawing back some of the recent losses.

Tidepool Investor's avatar

Thanks for the update Vince. Regarding $FTCH, do you see any chance of near-term turnaround (asset sales, debt paydowns, recovery in US/China markets) or do you think the stock goes even lower?

Vince Martin's avatar

Honestly, your guess is as good as mine near-term. Forced to choose, I think it goes higher as long as the broad market cooperates...investors have been willing to give these kinds of businesses multiple chances, and there is *something* here. You can build a bull case for a triple, even if it's tough to have a ton of confidence in that bull case.